26 Comments
Jul 22, 2021Liked by Kaizen Investing

Very insightful post. Thanks for putting it together. I'm not familiar with the nicotine industry so seeing the details on industry structure and distribution of product sales across types was super interesting.

I'm curious how you view the threat of non-traditional nicotine sales channels to the SWMA thesis. I've noticed Amazon lists competing nicotine pouch products and Zyn is nowhere to be found (https://www.amazon.com/s?k=nicotine+pouches). With MST & pouch sales still a small portion of the overall nicotine market and penetrating into new consumer buckets fast, this whitespace could be filled by rivals utilizing more convenient sales channels than a c-store. Given the stickiness of consumers to pouch brands/flavors, SWMA could lose out on the new basket of consumers buying from Amazon or other online channels. Do you view this as a material risk? But maybe the market is so large and it won't matter since SWMA is generating 233% incremental returns on capital :)

I can definitely speak to the stickiness of the products and how new non-traditional consumers are exploring the pouch products. On a tip from a friend, I recently tried a 3mg pouch and now can't stand to try any other brand/flavor. Prior to trying, I never smoked or dipped tobacco. One last thing - when I read people out there are taking 12mg pouches my jaw hit the floor. That's nuts to me.

Expand full comment
Jul 20, 2021Liked by Kaizen Investing

Amazing piece! The only thing I'd like to have read more about would be an analysis of the market valuation compared to peers in addition to the chart of Jon and why a multiples rerating of SWMA is not likely.

Expand full comment

"~0.2% of the TAM is penetrated"

Refreshing to see someone talk about TAM! You'd think it'd be a priority for most authors but its often absent 🤷‍♂️

Expand full comment
Dec 19, 2022Liked by Kaizen Investing

How did I miss this

Expand full comment
Jan 17, 2022Liked by Kaizen Investing

Absolutely brilliant piece.. Matches up very well with my own analysis and a bit of confirmation bias nevers hurt for a beautiful business like this.. Just one question/comment on the terminal value multiple... Have you tried the valuation using a EV/Free Cash Flow multiple instead of the EV/EBIT? And is there a reason you didnt use EV/Free Cash Flow.. Thanks again..

Expand full comment
Aug 11, 2021Liked by Kaizen Investing

Thanks, extremely good article!

I think you have correctly raised this risk, which could be quite important, which is that if Sweedish Match is the leader in smoke free in Scandinavia (54% marker share), but only has a 15% share of Nicotine Pouches, and the trend is an increasing demand of Nicotine Pouches, and they would be coming from the smoke free alternatives, how will this negatively impact Sweedish Match… is not a negligible part of the current business,

Regards!

Expand full comment
Jul 31, 2021Liked by Kaizen Investing

Listened to your podcast and followed you here. Great write-up. As a generalist who has never tried any tobacco products I had to google what the various nicotine products are. Would have benefited from a quick primer and links to the health effects of various options. You will always be amazed about how little some of your readers will know going in! I have a strict ESG policy where I am now allowed to buy any stocks my wife would disapprove too strongly :). This seems like a great way to get exposure to this industry. Love the low beta/economic exposure. And it does seem to trade at a low valuation given the quality and growth runway.

Expand full comment

Great read, can't wait for the next one!

Expand full comment

Im sorry but where could I find more info on incremental operating margin? You make a big point out of this but when I look up the smoke-free operating margin and it is 44.8% in Q4 2020.

How did you calculate it to get 99%?

Expand full comment
Jul 20, 2021Liked by Kaizen Investing

Very thoughtful write up of a fantastic company!

Expand full comment
Jul 20, 2021Liked by Kaizen Investing

Great work!

Expand full comment